Dealer.com Challenge – SEO vs Search Engine Marketing

by Paul on December 12, 2008

Search engine marketing is a great way to generate immediate traffic.  What is often overlooked by by car dealers is the real value of a well optimized site and an aggressive SEO campaign.  A recent post I did about dealership web traffic I referenced another post from Dealer.com on Drivingsales.com and feel that it was misconstrued based on the replies by Dealer.com.

Pay Per Click advertising has it’s place like for special promotions or a fresh site.  However at the end of the day there are so many studies out there that show that SEO provides better value than Seach Engine Marketing or PPC.  One of the best explanations was from Hubspot.com.

Their simple study showed that ranking number nine generates the same amout of leads and traffic as the number two paid listing.

From the post at Hubspot:

Here are the key takeaways from the data and the images above:

1) Organic results get 75%+ of the attention. People don’t click on the ads nearly as much as the organic results.

2) The first organic result gets over 25% of all clicks. Within the organic results, the first result gets the most clicks by far – more than double the second result.

3) Within the ads, the first ad also gets the most clicks. But, since you pay per click for the ads, you should care less about volume and more about if the traffic will actually convert and what your cost per lead and cost per sale will be.

4) There are a good number of clicks on all top 10 organic results. Even the last result gets about 3% of people to click on it – this is about the same rate as the second pay per click ad, and unlike the ad, its free!

SEO wins day in and day out.  Search engine marketing is an expensive way to drive traffic.  Contrary to popular belief SEO can be almost instant and that is the real purpose of this post to show how fast I can get it to rank for certain terms.  I bet it will be faster than the time it takes to set up a pay per click campaign.  Should see results in minutes not in ages, the term used to denigrate SEO.  I took it as a challenge from Dealer.com

I’ll report back with results.

  • Published at : 12:45 pm Decemember 12, 2008
  • Ranking #1 for : “Dealer.com Challenge – SEO vs Search Engine Marketing” 2:00 pm 12/12/08 < low value but indexed.
  • Ranking Number #6 for “dealer.com seo vs search engine marketing” 3:45 pm 12/12/08
  • Ranking #1 for “Dealer.com Search Engine Marketing” 7:00 pm 12/12/08

  • # 3 for dealer.com search marketing 8:00 pm 12/12/08
  • # 3 for dealer.com seo 8:00pm 12/12/08
  • #1 & #2 for dealer.com seo vs search engine marketing 10 am 12/13/08
  • #1 & #2 for dealer.com  search engine marketing vs seo 10 am 12/13/08
  • #1 for dealer.com seo 12/14/08
  • #1 for dealer.com search engine marketing 12/14/08
  • #1 for dealer.com search marketing 12/14/08
  • Going to stop tracking results now, and this page may fall out of favor, it was just a test to see how fast it would be to win search terms and show that it is not an ages long process.

images from Hubspot and MarketingSherpa

Recent post at www.drivingsales.com/blog


[CaRP] XML error: unclosed token at line 10 - This appears to be an HTML webpage, not a feed.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Brian Pasch December 12, 2008 at 11:40 pm

This is a great post and the heat map is a great demonstration of why SEO is very effective. In the economy, the heat map data and SEO’s great ROI should make this discussion priority #1 at 2009 Internet sales meetings.

David Robertson April 13, 2010 at 2:58 pm

Following the tutelage of this blog and others like it our car sales are increasing by the month. There’s no doubt as this excellent post points out and our results confess that SEO is the big way to help your customers find you! Find the right keywords and you’ve found your customer. Building business from SEO efforts takes time and effort. If you are willing to work harder and more diligently than your competition than you have the tools it takes to find yourself selling more of anything.

Leave a Comment

{ 5 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: